Tony Winning Kimberly Akimbo
Opens Season for Florida Studio Theatre
By: Jay Handelman - Nov 15, 2026
Preparing her audition for the title role in the Tony Award-winning musical “Kimberly Akimbo” at Florida Studio Theatre, Susan Haefner recalled that she didn’t have to reach far to play a 16-year-old girl with a congenital disorder that makes her age rapidly. Kimberly Levaco is a high school student who looks closer to 70.
“It was probably the easiest audition I’ve had in a long time. Kimberly feels right,” said the actress, who returns to FST for the production that runs Nov. 18-Jan. 3.
Playwright David Lindsay-Abaire reshaped his acclaimed 2001 off-Broadway play into a musical with composer Jeanine Tesori to tell the story of Kimberly as she tries to fit in and find her place in school while navigating a minefield at home. She lives with her alcoholic father, Buddy; her pregnant mother, Pattie, who has casts on both arms; and a visiting Aunt Debra prone to criminal activity. Kimberly appears to be the real adult in the house even though she’s still a kid.
Haefner, whose connection to
She actually hesitated to ask for an audition, even though she has performed in several shows at FST, most recently in the spring production of “Birthday Candles.”
“I didn’t want to ask for an audition because of fear of rejection,” she said in a recent joint interview with director and choreographer Ben Liebert. “I felt I was far too young to play her even though I’m in my 60s.”
Liebert said he saw a wide range of actors during the casting process.
“You’re looking for an actor who appears to be between 60 and 75 but who also gives the energy of a 16-year-old, and that’s an interesting balance to find,” he said. “It was interesting to see who could check all those boxes, who had the right look but you would believe is 16. Some we saw would never be believed as a teenager. They brought the maturity of 60 plus years, but not the life experience of only 16.”
Haefner said she played around with her hair and makeup for an initial taped audition.
“I started with this youthful look, with my hair up and a little makeup,” she said. “Then I pulled my hair down and thought of something I learned from a director who told me to stop smiling so much. When you don’t smile, the jowls show. I played around with just me. Smiling is my Broadway persona.”
Whatever she did worked.
“What Susan does so brilliantly is that she knows the stakes of Kimberly’s situation and still lives like a teenager,” Liebert said.
Haefner said she grew up trying hard to be the best every day. “One of my grades was an A- because I was too uptight,” she recalled. At the conservatory, a professor once told her to take a day off to go to the beach or play volleyball. “Relax,” she was told.
But Haefner was intent on reaching her goals.
“I wanted to be on Broadway within five years of graduating.” She met her goal, winning a role in the Rodgers and Hammerstein musical “State Fair” in 1996, before touring with Jerry Lewis in the musical “Damn Yankees” and returning to Broadway for “Thoroughly Modern Millie” and a revival of “
She’s rarely stopped acting in regional theaters in both plays and musicals, including “Come From Away,” “Mamma Mia,” “Fun Home” and “White Christmas,” or directing numerous productions.
In recent years, she has starred in a half dozen productions of “Tenderly: The Rosemary Clooney Musical,” a show she originated at the Cincinnati Playhouse.
“Working on Rosemary was a life-changing thing,” she said. She played the sometimes troubled singer from her 40s to about age 65. Haefner was in her 40s when the show had its debut in 2014 and she’s looking forward to going back to the role for another production now that she’s in her 60s.
Even with her determined attitude, “Tenderly” was another show she was sure would go to another actor. “I went to that audition assuming I wouldn’t get it. All these stars were auditioning. I was standing there in my power pose assuming I wouldn’t get it and by 6 o’clock I had the job.”
Because FST is one of the first regional theaters to stage the musical, Liebert said there was incredible interest among actors. As many as 9,000 actors submitted auditions or queries about the show with 300 to 400 of them specifically for Kimberly.
There are several roles for teenagers who are Kimberly’s classmates, including Seth, who works at a skating rink and befriends Kimberly.
“This material is intricate and tricky and very funny, but it also gets heavy at points,” Liebert said. “A lot of actors we saw were fresh out of school with zero life experience. We have people who look young but have some experience.”
One actor Haefner didn’t have to compete against was her longtime friend and
Liebert said the theater inquired about Morrison’s availability and she has “been very generous with her time and insights into the show.”
In a separate interview, Morrison said that after working with the original production team, including director Jessica Stone, she was less interested in doing the show again in a new production.
“I had fun every night, staying in the now, so everything was new to me for 10 months.” But when the tour ended, she was exhausted. “I crashed for about two months.”
Morrison said she was happily surprised that Stone gave her “a lot of freedom to play and explore. She really valued my perspective, which was lovely. I thought I was going to have to come in and be a cookie cutter, but there was room for little bits of interpretation.”
Liebert said that kind of freedom and flexibility is important in staging the show. When Haefner acknowledged that she has arthritis “we thought why not embrace it. That’s something that has worked for her as Kim.”
Looking ahead
Liebert and Haefner said that despite some of the tragic and serious elements in the story, the musical is funny and life-affirming,
“It’s really about learning how to live. How do we react when things happen to us. She has her disease, which is a given, a crazy family who she loves, and obstacles every step of the way, but she learns through all of that a way to live, every single moment and that personally hits a chord.”
Liebert said it’s hard to know “what’s going to happen tomorrow let alone six months from now. The message of the show is to live for now and that could not be more important now with the state of the world. This show gives us an opportunity to slow down, take a look around, see the beautiful sunsets we get here every day.”
“Kimberly Akimbo” by David Lindsay-Abaire and Jeanine Tesori. Directed and choreographed by Ben Liebert. Runs Nov. 18-Jan 3 in the Gompertz Theatre at Florida Studio Theatre,
To learn more and donate visit ArtsBeat.org.